Title

Human Rights, Labor, and the Prevention of Human Trafficking: A Response to A Labor Paradigm for Human Trafficking

Publication Title

UCLA Law Review Discourse

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

1-1-2013

Abstract

This Essay responds to an article by Hila Shamir previously published in the UCLA Law Review, in which she suggests that human rights has failed as a framework for addressing human trafficking and that instead a labor model would be more successful. Although her article identifies potentially important benefits of a labor perspective, the binary framework it establishes, pitting human rights and labor against each other, is counterproductive. Her article mischaracterizes the current antitrafficking framework and undervalues the importance of rights to a robust response to human trafficking. This Essay discusses the value of Professor Shamir’s labor paradigm and the role of human rights in antitrafficking responses. It then suggests that labor-based and human rights-based responses are not mutually exclusive, and that, ultimately, a successful response to human trafficking will need to incorporate strategies and methodologies from a range of perspectives.

Comments

External Links
Westlaw
Lexis Advance
Web
SSRN

Recommended Citation

Jonathan Todres, Human Rights, Labor, and the Prevention of Human Trafficking: A Response to A Labor Paradigm for Human Trafficking, 60 UCLA L. Rev. Discourse 142 (2013).

Volume

60

First Page

142

Last Page

158

This document is currently not available here.

Share

COinS